Joe and Charlie Big Book Study – “More About Alcoholism” – Joe W.

About This Speaker Tape

This session of the Joe and Charlie Big Book Study walks line by line through Chapter 3, "More About Alcoholism," framing the entire chapter as Bill W.'s case for alcoholic insanity — not craziness, but a mind that is "less than whole" and therefore cannot see the truth about alcohol just before the first drink. Joe opens by unpacking Step Two's promise of being restored to sanity, defining sanity from the dictionary as "wholeness of mind," and showing how obsession, illusion, delusion, and insanity are all used interchangeably in the chapter to mean believing a lie.

Charlie then leads the group through the three case studies Bill uses to prove the point: the Man of 30, who stayed dry 25 years and still died believing he could drink like other men; Jim, the low-bottom car salesman who put whiskey in his milk on a full stomach; and Fred, the high-bottom accountant who was on top of the world in a Washington hotel when the thought came that a couple of cocktails with dinner would be nice. In each case they drive home the same conclusion — the real problem centers in the mind telling us we can drink, not in the body that ensures we can't. The jaywalker analogy on page 37 is used as the perfect mirror for alcoholic thinking.

The session closes on page 43's "once more" paragraph — the alcoholic has no effective mental defense against the first drink, and that defense must come from a Higher Power. Charlie then shares a personal story about growing up Southern Baptist, defying Higher Power at age twelve after hearing that thinking about sin was the same as doing it, and arriving in AA at 38 with the spiritual understanding of a twelve-year-old — setting up why Bill had to write "We Agnostics" next.

Topics